Being a dog owner comes with plenty of decisions, and somewhere between picking the right food and finding the best spot for belly rubs, there’s the question of dog collars—practical, stylish, or something in between? A collar isn’t just an accessory; it’s something your dog wears every day, so comfort, durability, and the right fit all matter. The right choice can make your walks easier and keep your dog safe without them even noticing it’s there.
To help you make the right choice for your pup, we’re putting flat and rolled collars head-to-head, looking at the pros and cons, key differences, and when each one is a better option.
What is a Flat Collar?
Flat collars are the go-to choice for most dog owners—they’re the classic, adjustable design you’ll see on dogs everywhere. Typically made from nylon, leather, or other durable materials, they sit comfortably around the neck and fasten with either a buckle or quick-release clip.
Pros of Flat Collars:
- Easy to use: Quick to put on and take off, making them convenient for daily wear.
- Adjustable: Flat collars can be easily tightened or loosened to ensure the right fit as your pup grows.
- Variety of options: These collars are usually available in different materials, widths, and designs, so you’re bound to find one that suits your preferences.
- Ideal for ID tags: This keeps identification easily accessible in case your dog wanders off.
Cons of Flat Collars:
- Can cause matting: If your dog has long hair, the constant pressure can flatten or tangle their fur over time.
- Not the best for pullers: Does your dog tend to lunge or pull on the leash? A flat collar can put strain on their neck, which may lead to discomfort.
- Risk of slipping off: Some dogs, especially those with slim heads like Greyhounds, tend to back out of flat collars if it’s not fitted snugly.
Best Suited For:
Flat collars are an excellent choice for everyday wear and will suit most dogs, especially medium to larger breeds who don’t pull excessively on the leash. They’re also a good choice if your dog is comfortable walking on a loose lead and doesn’t have long fur that’s prone to matting.
What is a Rolled Collar?
Rolled collars have a rounded shape and are usually made from leather. These collars are designed to fit comfortably around the neck without pressing down on the fur. The rolled shape helps reduce matting and tangles, making them a preferred choice for long-haired breeds.
Pros of Rolled Collars:
- Better for long-haired breeds: The rounded shape helps prevent fur from matting or tangling around the neck.
- Comfortable fit: Rolled collars have a smooth, curved design that reduces pressure points, making them a good fit for dogs with sensitive skin.
- Durable material: Leather is a strong and long-lasting material that softens over time, which might be more comfortable for your pup.
Cons of Rolled Collars:
- Less adjustable: Most rolled collars have buckle closures with fixed holes, which means they may not offer as precise a fit as flat collars.
- Can be pricier: The leather material tends to cost more than nylon or fabric options, so expect to shell out a bit extra for quality.
- Not ideal for heavy pullers: The rounded shape can put more pressure on a small area of the neck, which is not ideal if you’ve got a pup that tends to pull hard on the leash.
What’s the Difference Between the Two?
Aside from how they look, there’s more to choosing between flat and rolled collars. Here’s how they compare in key areas:
Design & Comfort
Flat collars sit flush against your dog’s neck—this means pressure is distributed evenly for that classic, familiar fit. Rolled collars, on the other hand, have a rounded shape, which helps reduce fur matting and irritation. This makes the latter a better option for your long-haired pup or if you’ve got a dog with sensitive skin.
Material
Rolled collars are usually made from leather, which is durable and softens over time. However, it will need more care as it needs to be conditioned to prevent drying or cracking. In contrast, flat collars are commonly made from nylon, polyester, or leather, which will give you more options when it comes to colours and patterns.
Durability
While both collars can last a long time with proper care, leather rolled collars tend to be sturdier than nylon flat ones. Just keep in mind that leather tends to crack if it gets too dry, while nylon is generally more resistant to water and rough outdoor conditions.
Adjustability
Flat collars usually come with adjustable buckles or quick-release clasps that make it easier to get the right fit. Rolled collars—especially those with traditional buckle closures—may have fewer size holes. This can make sizing less flexible, especially if you’ve got a growing pup.
Ease of Use
Flat collars with snap closures are quick and easy to put on and take off, making them a practical option for day-to-day wear. Rolled collars, particularly leather ones with buckle closures, take a bit more time to fasten, but the trade-off here is a more secure fit once in place.
Which Collar Should I Get for My Dog?
No single collar works for every dog—what fits a sturdy Labrador might not suit a smaller, finer-coated Cavalier King Charles Spaniel. The best collar depends on the following factors:
Breed & Neck Size
Larger breeds, like Labradors and German Shepherds, tend to do well with flat collars since they distribute pressure more evenly around the neck. On the other hand, smaller breeds or those with delicate necks—like Daschunds or Chihuahuas—may find rolled collars more comfortable, as they’re gentler and less likely to dig into their skin.
Skin Sensitivity
Some dogs have skin that’s prone to irritation, especially short-haired breeds like Greyhounds, Dobermans, and Boxers. A rolled collar has rounded edges that help prevent chafing and reduce friction against the skin. If your dog has had issues with rubbing or fur matting from a flat collar before, consider switching to a rolled design.
Activity Level
How active is your pup? If your dog is always on the move—running, hiking, or swimming—a flat collar made from nylon or waterproof-coated materials is a good option. They’re easier to clean and dry quickly, which is perfect for days on the go. If your dog spends most of their time lounging at home or going on casual walks around the neighbourhood, a rolled leather collar could be a more comfortable choice.
When to Use Each Type of Collar
The right collar isn’t just about fit—it should also suit your dog’s routine and needs. Some situations call for the simplicity of a flat collar, while others make a rolled collar the better option.
Flat Collars
A flat collar is a go-to for most dog owners as they’re practical and easy to use. If your pup wears a collar all day for identification tags, a flat design will sit comfortably against their neck. It’s also the easier option for everyday walks—just clip on a leash, and you’re out the door.
For dogs that love a good outdoor adventure, a nylon flat collar can handle splashes, dirt, and rough play without much fuss. Leather collars can also work well for active dogs, just make sure to give them a bit of care now and then to keep them in good condition.
Best for: Daily wear, dogs that are frequently on a leash, medium to large breeds, active dogs
Rolled Collars
If your dog has a thick or long coat, a rolled collar can help prevent matting. The rounded edges reduce friction, making it an excellent option for breeds that tend to get tangled fur around the neck. We also recommend rolled collars for dogs with sensitive skin as there’s less flat surface pressing against their coat.
Leather rolled collars are durable, but they do require a bit more care, especially if your dog spends a lot of time in wet or muddy environments. They’re ideal for dogs that mostly hang out indoors or in gentler conditions.
Best for: Dogs with long or thick fur, dogs prone to skin irritation, short-haired breeds needing a gentler fit
Choosing Based on Lifestyle
- Training & Control: If your dog’s in training or tends to pull on the lead, a flat collar gives you better control. Some come with extra features, like a martingale loop, for a snugger fit without causing any discomfort.
- Outdoor Adventures: Dogs who love hiking, swimming, or rolling the grass will benefit from a waterproof or quick-drying flat collar. Rolled leather collars are tough, but they do need a bit more care if exposed to water and mud often.
- Relaxation & Comfort: For dogs that spend most of their time relaxing at home, comfort’s key. A rolled collar is perfect for dogs with sensitive skin or those who only wear a collar for ID purposes.
Common Collar Problems and How to Avoid Them
Even the best collar can cause a few issues if it’s not the right fit or isn’t used properly. Here’s what to watch out for to keep your pup comfortable:
Skin Irritation
Is your dog constantly scratching at their collar? It might be rubbing the wrong way. Some dogs react to certain materials, and others just don’t do well with anything too tight. Leather can soften over time, but synthetic materials might cause chafing, especially in hot weather. A quick fix? Check the fit—if you can’t slip two fingers under your dog’s collar, it’s too snug. Also, make sure you’re giving their beck a breather by taking the collar off indoors when it’s safe to do so.
Fur Matting and Bald Spots
Long-haired dogs can end up with tangled or thinning fur where the collar sits, especially if it’s a flat design that presses down on their coat. Rolled collars help reduce friction, but no matter what type you use, it’s always a good idea to take the collar off now and then to let their fur settle. Brushing the area regularly will also prevent knots from forming.
Collar-Related Injuries
A collar that’s too loose can get caught on things, while one that’s too tight can put pressure on the throat. Dogs that pull hard on the lead are at a higher risk of neck strain, so if your pup tends to lunge, a harness might be the better option for walks. For everyday wear, keep the collar snug but not restrictive, and check for signs of redness or discomfort around the neck.
Keeping Collars Clean and Comfortable
Sweat, dirt, and a bit of dog slobber can build up over time, making collars stiff and smelly. Fabric and nylon collars can usually go in the easy, while leather ones just need a quick wipe-down with a damp cloth and the occasional conditioning to keep them from drying out. Regular cleaning keeps things fresh and stops dirt and bacteria from causing skin irritation.
Are There Other Options Out There?
Flat and rolled collars do the job for most dogs, but they’re not the only options out there. Depending on your dog’s needs, other types might be a better fit.
Harnesses give you more control and take pressure off the neck, making them a great pick for dogs that pull or have respiratory issues. Head collars guide your dog’s head to help with training. Although they take some getting used to, they can be useful for reducing lunging. Martingale collars are another choice. These collars tighten slightly when pulled, making them ideal for dogs with narrow heads—like greyhounds—that can slip out of regular collars.
Finding the Right Collar for Your Dog
Both flat and rolled collars have their place, and the best choice comes down to what suits your dog’s needs. Flat collars are a solid everyday option, especially for larger or more active dogs, while rolled collars help prevent fur matting and are gentler on sensitive skin.
Think about your dog’s breed, coat type, and lifestyle when making your pick. If they love outdoor adventure, a sturdy collar might be the way to go. If your pup has delicate fur or skin that’s prone to irritation, a rolled collar could be a better fit.
Check out our range of collars, made with quality materials for comfort and durability. Whether you’re after something practical or a bit more stylish, there’s a great option for your pup.
